Writer: Gregg Hurwitz
Jervis Tetch's father made hats. Jervis dated a girl named Alice Dee when he was in high school. Their first date was to an Alice in Wonderland theme park. It was a perfect day for young Jervis. Now, as the Mad Hatter, he is kidnapping people all over Gotham and forcing them to re-enact that day in a sort of play so that he can relive it.
The only problem is that when Jervis' goons, Tweedle Dee and Tweedle Dum, try to kidnap a child, Batman stops them and then puts a homing device on them so that he can track them to Jervis' headquarters.